Horkheimer and Adorno | Dialectic of Enlightenment

The first book of my Cultural Studies seminar with Thomas Rickert this semester is Horkheimer and Adorno’s Dialectic of Enlightenment, first published in German in 1944 near the end of WWII. The book was translated into English first in 1972 and again in 2002 (the edition I cite below). Here, I thought I’d share some class discussion notes, as well as my own reflections of their ideas, which surprisingly, shockingly and sadly, are still very relevant today.

History of Frankfurt School

The Frankfurt School emerged from Marxism, with which they weren’t completely satisfied. They questioned Marx’s theory of the dialectic—the rise of the communist state—(if that doesn’t work, why not?), feeling that Marxist theory relied too much on objectivity.

Their major influences:

  • Freud’s Civilization and Its Discontents | Civilization automatically makes us repressed
  • Nietzsche | Enlightenment will turn on itself and produce barbarism; 1800s
  • Empirical Work
  • Social Theory

Their major concerns:

  • Economic Industry | Deregulated capital; slight shift with economic distribution; new technology that disseminate economic info differently, though we can’t get away from it. Domination is not just economic, but also cultural.
  • Culture Industry | keeps us narcotized; digital soma for the masses. Culture is ideological; it teaches you that the way things are are the ways things ought to be. Theory itself is cultural.
  • Historical Domination| The domination we see in our everyday lives are not contemporary alone, but go very far back. Pre-literate people (magic and animism—the idea that animals and things have souls; indicates that they read archaeology and anthropology).
  • Reject Positivism | the idea that empirical, objective studies of reality simply render what reality is. i.e. a truck is a truck. In response, the Frankfurters say a truck is a concept/symbol/object within a system.
  • Theory Itself is Cultural | This is why they attend to how their own theory can be commoditized or not commoditized; how can our theory disrupt an ideology of naturalism that says, “This is just the way the world works. Here are some rich people and everyone else suffers, and that’s just the way it is.”

Dialectic between myth and enlightenment | Most evident moment of the refusal of exteriority; myth is something that used to be true before people considered themselves “Enlightened”; myth is produced as a concept emerging out of Enlightenment (reminds me of Heidegger’s caution toward the concept and Toulmin’s view of concepts made possible because of Enlightenment). Where the ratinoal disenchantment of the world reverts to myth. Enlightenment emerges from our ability to experience the world through our work within it (24-5).

*How does myth become Enlightenment? What’s the relationship between the two? Myth becomes Enlightenment because of repeated referencing/touching-back of human understanding. Myth today is only understood as myth (in the fantasmic sense) because we have rejected it for new “Enlightened” reasoning, which of course also gets rejected with new “findings”: “But the myths which fell victim to the Enlightenment were themselves its products” (5). The problem of Enlightenment for H&A is that is rests too strongly on the ideal of clear and “natural” truth. Whatever is outside of this “magic circle” drawn by enlightenment is simply ignored:

“For enlightenment, anything which does not conform to the standard of calculability and utility must be viewed with suspicion. Once the movement is able to develop unhampered by external oppression, there is no holding it back. Its own ideas of human rights then fare no better than the older universals. Any intellectual resistance it encounters merely increases its strength” (3).

Adorno and Horkheimer | Style Their long paragraph styles play against commonly-accepted, sound-bited styles; they are working against commodified style as a performance of reaction and ; ideology is not simply a narrative; styles often project and forward commodities and A&H here attempt to encourage readers to question sound-bites and consumptive reading: “Intellect’s true concern is a negation of reification. It must perish when it is solidified into a cultural asset and handed out for consumption purposes” (xvii). Clarity is ideological; A&H want to develop a negative relationship to clarity. Conditions of production influence this as well: “We dictated long stretches together” (Preface to 1969 Edition). Adorno spoke into a dictophone (tape-recorder).

Mass Culture | is commoditized into everyday life and therefore, it is limited in its emancipator abilities. Later, Hebdige and other cultural theorists will reject this as too cynical. H&A though see all things as part of massive systems (i.e. mass culture), and hope that dialectical thinking (what they call Critical Theory—yes, a precursory to the “thing” CT is today) can help us emerge from the system… later, Hawkhee and Bay will suggest that this occurs in “temporary autonomous zones.”

  • I believe this gives a lot of support to the study of rhetoric, where we seek to understand how systems of representation influence or affect. I wonder also how this will relate to new materialisms?
  • Later, Jameson will ask: Is critique really possible, or does it just perpetuate the larger system?
  • Even in online communities, we can’t escape a forced division of labor; it simply repeats itself. Our classrooms too. Could relate also to subculture as a tech tool.

About taylo206

I am an Assistant Professor of Composition, Rhetoric and Professional Writing at Miami University in Oxford, Ohio.
This entry was posted in Embodiment, Public Rhetorics, Theories of Composition and Rhetoric. Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to Horkheimer and Adorno | Dialectic of Enlightenment

  1. Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering if you knew of any widgets I could add to my blog that automatically tweet my newest twitter updates.
    I’ve been looking for a plug-in like this for quite some time and was hoping maybe you would have some experience with something
    like this. Please let me know if you run into anything.
    I truly enjoy reading your blog and I look forward to your new updates.

  2. Remarqսablke article, continuez de cetе façon

  3. Talk with neighbors who may be able to pick up food
    or prescriptions while they run their errands. As being a separating shot listed below are what involving super-star Keanu
    Beckham: ‘At initial When i has been worried My spouse
    and i has been petrified. The particular financial plan spectrum is usually finding
    an occasion associated with unprecedented growth.

  4. Jaxon says:

    You should be a part of a contest for one of the
    greatest blogs on the web. I am going to recommend
    this web site!

  5. I’d likе tο find out more? I’d care to find out ѕome additional іnformation.

  6. Different porous materials are found to make this kind of concrete product.
    If the plunger method fails, you do have several other options that you
    may want to try. The price component is instantly influenced; this in turn is a concern on an monetary family to deal with the price of modern living.

  7. One of the main misconceptions about glass is that it is rather dull with practically no privacy. With all the new advances in technology- that
    is simply just not the case anymore.

    Over the years, glass manufacturers have come up with various types of
    glass like double glazed windows and patterned glass.
    You can use glass doors for your bathroom, patio and other
    places at your house to give your home an ultramodern or elegant look and feel.

    So you do not have to worry about the glass being dull or plain. Purchasing glass that
    has etched designs of nature like flowers and trees or any other categories based on your personal taste is possible nowadays.
    So finding the right kind of glass to blend with other furnishings in a particular
    room is indeed possible. There is no shortage of choices in terms of glass

    Another benefit of glass is in terms of insulation. Glass is not a good
    conductor of heat. During our hot summer season, with all the advances in energy efficiency with
    glass, glass will not absorb heat, making
    the room hotter. During a winter or autumn period, glass will not cause
    much heat loss. 

    So you and your family might enjoy a more cooling effect during summer and a warmer effect during
    winter or autumn. You also save money in terms of utility bills.
    Since there is less heat loss, you can turn down the
    heating system to a lower temperature, which results in less energy consumption.
    During summer, there would not be any necessity to lower the temperature. 

    Another benefit of using glass doors and windows is that it
    just makes your home brighter and more cheerful feeling. With our famous sunny days, there might be
    no necessity to switch on lights to light up a particular place since
    there is sufficient natural light.

  8. LinkedIn has a great feature that connects with your existing email accounts and allows you to invite anyone you have interacted with to your network.
    This means that you might reach people you interacted with once or twice, or people that you haven’t
    spoken with in a while. This is a powerful tool, but are you using it effectively
    in your marketing?
    LinkedIn as a Data Collector
    Look at all the ways you can collect data from
    people. The easiest metric to track for most is their email addresses, so ask people and promote their use.
    Create mailers or offer contests via email registration. Remember, each email you
    collect is another potential LinkedIn profile waiting to be connected to.
    Also, you might convince someone to join LinkedIn when they receive an invite from you, which means more customers to interact with.

    Easy Ways to Connect on LinkedIn
    So, what are some easy ways to connect with users and get
    them to want to network with you? Many companies have started suing
    LinkedIn as a corporate blog to promote brand awareness. These blogs might not
    even have anything to do with the products being sold, but they might tie in with corporate
    culture or offer up some helpful knowledge or technique.

    This is called generating substance, and if you want people to see a value in your postings, you need
    to provide that substance, otherwise they simply won’t care.

    The nice thing about this is you don’t have to be a multi-faceted
    business guru to provide content. Maybe you promote an interesting link of the day, or maybe you repost a news story about something
    company-related (please give credit if you do this.).
    It could even be a humorous blurb or story, or even a
    business-appropriate joke to keep your network’s attention. The only constant is that the
    postings stay constant. If you start it, then maintain it to help build that brand awareness.

    Remember, people won’t actively look for you if they don’t know you exist.

    One great way that some companies have started building a loyalty network is through
    promoting their employees. Some companies will offer a spotlight on their employees, showing
    off the projects they have done or discussing their high points.
    This not only helps to ensure your employees feel valued, but it also helps to paint your company as
    more human, which is something you want when trying to get people to connect with
    Pitfalls and Things to Avoid With LinkedIn
    Most of what has been discussed here has been the positives of using LinkedIn for your promotions, but there are some pitfalls you may want to avoid.
    Again, not all marketing works for all niches and some can be turned off more easily than others.

    For starters, when advertising with a graphic, consider the context that your audience will view it in. LinkedIn is business
    to business networking. Is your picture one that would
    be considered safe for a business networking platform? Yes,
    attractive, nearly-naked people tend to get clicks, but are those the kind of ads people at major corporations are going to be more than likely be turned off
    due to lack of professionalism? Consider your content in your pictures before posting and make sure
    your graphics are a good match to your audience and marketing
    Second, watch your language. While on the surface, this
    could be taken as do not swear, on a deeper level, you have to consider what a company will filter for and what they will allow.
    Some words tend to trigger web filters pretty easily, so be careful about your verbiage.
    Also, look at the message your words send. Are you trying to be edgy, dynamic, endearing?

    Do your words properly convey the message you want people to see?
    Sometimes people get so wrapped up in sending out a strong
    message that they fail to consider if it is the right one.
    Third, don’t verbally tie yourself to a region or company if you can help it.
    While you may want to highlight a company on a
    landing page or maybe you are geared towards a certain region of the world, you don’t want to inadvertently exclude potential customers because they think your ads don’t immediately apply to them.
    Remember, you can focus your ads in terms of companies and locations ahead of
    time, so listing out that info in the actual ad might prove
    Fourth, don’t slack on your content. It can be easy to start with a big push, but the number one thing that kills an audience’s interest is
    inconsistency. Don’t slouch on your posts. Make sure you dedicate a certain period of time each day to
    providing some form of content. If you can’t or think you might have problems with this, hire someone to do it for you
    or spend a day or two generating multiple posts so that you
    can just plug and play. However you do it, just be sure to keep doing it.
    You are setting an expectation of service as accompany when you post, and to do so inconsistently will send
    a bad message abour what your company considers professional.

    Fifth, be careful on rebranding. Some smaller companies take
    the philosophy of experimentation a bit too far and
    keep trying to reinvent themselves every month or
    quarter, but the truth of it is that many companies
    form bonds over the long term with clients, and
    just because you announce a name change or a new logo, that doesn’t mean that your clientele is paying attention. To build your brand, you
    need consistency, so stick to a logo or name and try
    to avoid being so edgy that you can’t make up your
    mind about your name. Remember, you’re a business, not a rock
    LinkedIn Final Thoughts
    LinkedIn is a wonderful tool for reaching people in the business world.

  9. XXX says:

    Je ѵais finir de jeter un coսp d’oeil à ça plus tard

  10. Jе suis entièrement d’accorԀ avec vous

  11. Tonja says:

    Irrespective of where your home is, chances
    are we could present an incredible trainer in your town and you.
    It is possible to take lessons while in the solitude of your own home or at your teacher’s place.
    Start by looking in your ZIP code to get educators in your area.
    In terms of neighborhood vs. game. You will never fully
    repeat streets while in the gym. & most definitely not within your roleplaying maga gym.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s